If You’d Be Embarrassed to Put It on Your PDP, Don’t Post It

There’s a simple gut check brands should run before hitting “publish” on social content:

Would you be comfortable putting this on your product detail page?

If the answer is no…you probably shouldn’t post it anywhere.

That might sound extreme. Social media is supposed to be looser, more fun, more “human,” right? Sure. But social content doesn’t live in a vacuum anymore. It’s not just entertainment. It’s discovery, validation, and pre-purchase research whether brands like it or not.

And increasingly, it’s being judged through the same lens as your PDP.

Social Is No Longer Separate From Commerce

Once upon a time, social content could be sloppy, ironic, or half-baked because it was “just social.” That era is over.

Today, social posts:

• Get screenshotted and shared in buying conversations
• Influence reviews and star ratings downstream
• Surface in AI search results and zero-click answers
• Act as unofficial product education

In other words, your Instagram Reel might not be your PDP…but it absolutely influences whether someone trusts it.

The Content Brands Would Never Ship (But Do Anyway)

Most brands would never approve the following for their PDP:

• Blurry footage that doesn’t clearly show the product
• Vague claims with no proof or context
• Jokes that undermine quality, durability, or performance
• Trend hopping that feels off-brand or forced

Yet those exact things show up on social feeds every day, justified by “authenticity” or “playing the algorithm.”

Authenticity doesn’t mean careless. And relatability doesn’t mean credibility goes out the window.

Authentic vs. Trustworthy Isn’t a Tradeoff

Here’s the misconception: that content has to choose between being polished or being real.

That’s a false choice.

Some of the highest-performing content today looks casual, but still:

• Clearly demonstrates the product in use
• Answers real buyer questions
• Reinforces why the product exists
• Feels aligned with the brand’s promise

If a piece of content would actively weaken your PDP, confuse a shopper, or make a retailer nervous…it’s not “real,” it’s risky.

A Better Rule of Thumb

Before posting, ask:

• Does this help someone understand the product better?
• Does it reinforce trust or erode it?
• Would I feel confident if a retailer or AI surfaced this as “representative” content?

If the answer is yes, post away.

If not, rethink it…or don’t post it at all.

Because social content isn’t disposable anymore. It’s part of the buying experience.

And if you’d be embarrassed to put it on your PDP, your audience probably feels the same way.

‍